Sunday, May 29, 2011

Cornet Mouthpiece Throat Sizes

Following on from my article about choosing a cornet mouthpiece which includes a discussion of balancing out the resistance I thought I would share my knowledge of  cornet mouthpiece throat sizes. I have converted the sizes to US drill sizes for easier comparison. For a description of what these sizes mean see Jim Donaldson's very informative article here.

Throat size is one element in determining the resistance of the system (the others being instrument bore size, mouthpiece gap and embouchure aperture). Its possible to compensate against a very resistive instrument by using a mouthpiece with a larger throat (bore) size or against a very open instrument by using a tighter mouthpiece.

Bach
Standard - #27, 3.66mm
Megatone - #26, 3.73mm (larger throat designed to overcome the tight feeling that results from the larger mass of the megatone mouthpiece)

Bach used to (maybe still) do custom mouthpiece work and I have seen a 5V (very deep V cup) with a larger #20 throat that was stamped "20" in the factory.

Schilke
Standard line - #26 (except models with "A" backbore which are #27)

Schilke now make deep V shaped "symphony" models. I do not know what throat sizes these use.


Denis Wick
Models without letters - 4.6mm #15
except: 2 which is #14
B models - 4.3mm #18
S model - 4.1mm #20

These mouthpieces were originally designed for the old Imperial and early Sovereign cornets which had more resistance than current models. I feel that they tend to encourage over blowing in modern, freer blowing, instruments. Wick seem to have recognise this issue by making  a 4 ½ which is identical to the 4 but with a narrower #16 throat.

Curry
BBC (Brass Band Cornet) - 4.07mm #20
VC (Vintage Cornet) -  #18
DC (Deep Cornet) - #25

Yamaha (short shank)
11E4 - 4.2mm #20
16E & 14E - 3.98mm #22
David King - 4.60mm #15 (presumably influenced by the Wick standard of larger throats)

Warburton
Long shank (standard) #27
(Warburton make #23 mouthpieces as a standard option so these are also in circulation but marked "23")
Short shank with "BC" tops for UK market #20 (unconfirmed though as I have not seen one personally)


Other factors
The shape of the cup of a mouthpiece also affects resistance with flatter, shallower cups generally being more resistive. You can test the relative resistances of two mouthpieces by running a constant stream of water into them from a tap and observing how much it will take before the cup starts to overflow. Its surprising how much some apparently small mouthpieces will take (try comparing a smaller Jet-Tone trumpet mouthpiece with a standard Bach 7c - the apparently small Jet-Tone will handle as much flow).

1 comment:

  1. Very interesting article Gordon.Thank you very much. I agree with everything you say as I have been experementing with drill sizes in both Cornet and Trumpet mouthpieces and i totally agree that the mouthpiece throat drill size is one of the most important aspects of the mouth piece that can be easly altered to balance it to the horn. One is able to retain all the other aspects of ones favorite mouthpiece and enable it to make the overall blow/resistance match your needs. I have heard too many trumpet players in my time critisize a perfectly good instrument when quite often it is either the back bore or the drill size of the mouthpiece that is not a good match for the horn that they are reviewing. To put it in a motor mechanics terms. The needle in the carburetta must must be the right size to allow the correct flow. Trumpet bore sizes supplied by the manafacturers can be very confusing as many trumpets bore sizes will vary throughout the same instrument. Many famous trumpets have the same conical bore design as a cornet but with a trumpet wrap instead of the exta varied wraps a cornet will have. Many large bor horns will have a smaller bell bore size than the main bore of the instrument. Anyone wanting to continue with this interesting conversation can contact me at richard.autenzio@bigpond.com.

    ReplyDelete